The Times Up mouse trap is excellent. It’s by far the best mouse trap that I’ve ever used, in terms of catch-rates, the % of clean kills, and the low rate of bait-theft. They’re only cheap plastic, but they’d held up really well.
I started with 2 traps to try them out, and bought another 6 a few weeks later, because the results were so good. I’ve made 2 double-set tunnels for them, with 1/2" access holes, and a quad trap.
Since the start of April, I’ve killed 84. My total for 2021 was 58 mice, so I’m on pace to probably triple last year’s total. This was over a pretty small area, so there are WAY more mice that I had thought there were, and some rather large mice that may have actually been young rats. Since I started trapping droves of mice, the amount of bait-theft in my DoC tunnels has plummeted. Every now and then, I disarm the mouse traps to let them clean the traps for me, to prevent mold colonising the tunnels, which has worked very well, so far.
I’m moving the quad tunnels from 1 DoC tunnel to another, in order to reduce the local population, and to supply my DoC tunnels with fresh mouse bait. Mice are #1 on the menu of female stoats and weasels, so it should pay off, eventually. Having a mouse tunnel next to a DoC tunnel also creates lots of mouse scent-trails, creating free lures. Presumably, all of these scent trails, ideally coming from different directions, should help to lure predators to underperforming DoC tunnels.
Regarding bait, in general, I’ve found that squishing a single dry chickpea on top of peanut butter, a Goodnature lure, Marmite, etc. can work because the sticky base makes the chickpea stick to it. I’ve trapped plenty of mice that try to steal the chickpea, or that try to move it out of the way to get at the base bait.
I hope this helps.
Cheers.